Step into history with this stunning three-story Victorian, built in 1900, offering over 2,500 sq. ft. of character, charm, and modern updates. Perfectly situated on a corner lot within walking distance to downtown Palmyra, this home is the best of both worlds; timeless elegance meets everyday convenience. From the moment you enter the grand foyer, you’ll be captivated by the intricate original woodwork, soaring ceilings, and two ornate fireplaces. Spacious rooms flow seamlessly, with working pocket doors that add to the historic charm.
The updated kitchen is a true centerpiece with custom cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, and a large butcher block island that’s perfect for entertaining. Both bathrooms have been thoughtfully updated, and there’s even a convenient main floor laundry. Upstairs, the second-floor landing makes an ideal sitting room or reading nook, while the home’s flexible layout offers three bedrooms with the potential for up to five. The third floor reno has been started and awaits your finishing touches, adding even more usable living space to this massive home.
Other highlights include maintenance-free vinyl siding, double-pane vinyl replacement windows, and an outdoor storage shed that conveys with the property. This home isn’t just spacious, it’s an incredible value for the price. Whether you’re looking for room to grow, space to entertain, or a chance to own a piece of Palmyra’s history, this Victorian delivers it all. Sellers will provide a one-year home warranty with an acceptable offer.
Room Features
Basement DescriptionCellar, Crawl Space
Lot & Building Features
AppliancesOven, Range Hood, Refrigerator, Dishwasher
ArchitectureVictorian
ConstructionFrame
CoolingWindow Unit(s), Ceiling Fan(s), Central Air
HeatingBaseboard, Electric, Natural Gas, Forced Air
SewerPublic Sewer
Tax Year2024
Taxes Paid$839
WaterPublic
Fireplaces2
Community and Schools
Elementary SchoolPalmyra Elem.
Junior High SchoolPalmyra Middle
Senior High SchoolPalmyra High
Price History of 222 New Street, Palmyra, MO
Date
Name
Price
Difference
01/21/2026
Price Adjustment
$235,000
2.04%
10/21/2025
Price Adjustment
$239,900
3.07%
09/08/2025
Price Adjustment
$247,500
0.96%
08/19/2025
Listing Price
$249,900
N/A
*Information provided by REWS for your reference only. The accuracy of this information cannot be verified and is not guaranteed.
222 New Street (MLS #25056916) is a 3+ story single family home located in Palmyra, MO.
This single family home is 2,558 sqft and on a lot of 9,148 sqft (or 0.21 acres) with 4 bedrooms and 2 baths. This property was listed on 08/19/2025 and has been priced for sale at $235,000.
The 3 bedroom single family home at 124 W Ross Street in Palmyra is nearby and sold for $212,000 on 08/13/2025. Another nearby 4 bedroom single family home, 621 S Breckenridge Avenue in Palmyra sold for $180,000 on 06/26/2025.
Listing Last updated . Some properties which appear for sale on this web site may subsequently have sold or may no longer be available. Walk Score map and data provided by Walk Score. Google map provided by Google. Bing map provided by Microsoft Corporation.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.
Listing information courtesy of: Happel Inc. Realtors
Listings displaying the MARIS logo are courtesy of the participants of Mid America Regional Information Systems Internet Data Exchange